Let us protectwhat matters most

Auto Insurance

Michigan provides the best auto insurance benefits in the country if you're injured in an accident. We can shop multiple different companies to find what will work for you.

Find out more

Home Insurance

Your home is likely one of the biggest investments you'll make. Let us help you find the coverage to protect you and your belongings.

Get covered


We offer a wide variety of options for just about every industry from contractors, to auto repair shops, to large and small business owners, equipment rental stores and more.

Protect your business

Community Involvement

When you do business locally with us, we are able to turn around and support many great causes in central Michigan.

People Matter

Contact a Team Member

Our team has over 200 combined years of experience in the insurance industry. We are ready to help you protect you, your family, and your business from the unexpected.

We know insurance

What People Are Saying

Check out what our clients are saying about their experiences with us.


Mt. Pleasant Agency – Central Insurance

Founded in 1959, our Michigan-based agency is an Independent Insurance Agency offering peace of mind to families and businesses throughout Michigan for auto, home, farm, business, and life insurance needs. We partner with excellent companies to provide a variety of options for our clients. Mt. Pleasant Agency – Central Insurance represents 14 different companies and we are a preferred partner with most of our carriers. We are a Trusted Choice and Total Quality Agency and were publicly voted 2017’s People’s Choice insurance agency for all of Isabella County. We continue to grow each year having acquired four agencies since 1982. Our main priority is to protect our customers with a diverse plan to include home, auto, business, income, and lawsuit protection.

We love our community. We love our neighbors. We’re committed to protecting them better than anyone else. As an Independent Insurance Agency, we offer a high level of customized insurance services and products to meet our clients’ needs. 100% of our team members are licensed and all are committed to providing unsurpassed service to each of our clients. Because our products are not something that our customers can see, feel, or touch, it’s critical that we demonstrate integrity. That’s why it’s one of our core values along with trust, honesty, and hard work. We also believe that education and knowledge are crucial in understanding what our clients are purchasing from us. We strive to help our customers manage their risks and have open conversations with them so we can identify where they may need additional protection.


Learn More Find a Location

Don't wait

Request a quote today!

Call us at 989-772-2977

Our Carriers

See what our clients have to say

Lee & Carole Kennett Mt. Pleasant, MI
A ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Agency! A friendly, knowledgeable, attentive and ethical staff who find the best insurance coverage to fit our needs. We have had our insurance with them for years and recommend them very highly. Also love their support and dedication to projects within the Mt. Pleasant community that make Mt. Pleasant "Someplace Special."
Amy Motz Shellberg-Fisher Holding Co, Mt. Pleasant, MI
Mt. Pleasant Agency - Central Insurance has taken care of all of my insurance needs for nearly 25 years... home, auto and business and I would highly recommend them. The staff is so very helpful and friendly whenever I have questions and I enjoy working with a local, personable firm that understands my needs. They are always there when I need them. Their motto of "Insurance with Integrity" says it all!
Jack Neyer Mt. Pleasant Realty Mt. Pleasant, MI
Thank you and your staff for all of your help during our loss. You and your firm did a wonderful job, and are greatly appreciated. Thanks to you and your great team.
Rhonda Wernette Blanchard, MI
Mt. Pleasant Agency was very helpful and prompt.
Carmelina Crisci Mt. Pleasant, MI
If you're looking for an insurance company you can trust and will work very hard at getting you the best rates they can then I would recommend Mt. Pleasant Agency, Inc - Central Insurance. We have been with them for over 6 years and their professional and courteous staff have always been there for us and worked hard to make sure when our basement flooded that our needs were tended to. When I rolled my vehicle they were there every step of the way making sure that I was taken care of. I would highly recommend them for all of your insurance needs.
David Allen Allen Renovations Mt. Pleasant, MI
They were and are very helpful. I'm overall impressed with them.